Skip to main content

Recognizing the causes of rolling element bearing failures

Assuming proper design, application, and lubrication, rolling element bearings will fail sooner or later due to their natural material fatigue life limit, but all bearings will fail prematurely from abuse or neglect.

BY L. (TEX) LEUGNER

Troubleshooting of rolling element bearing problems and recognizing their root cause of failure is often difficult, because many failure types look very similar. This is because bearing failures are almost always precipitated by spalling or flaking conditions of the bearing component surfaces. Spalling occurs when a bearing has reached its fatigue life limit, but also when premature failures occur. For this reason, it is important for the troubleshooter to be aware of and able to recognize all the common failures of rolling element bearings. This ability to correctly troubleshoot and recognize the root cause of bearing failures will lead the analyst to the right conclusions. We often hear the comment, even by knowledgeable and well-meaning engineers and technicians, “this bearing failed prematurely because it was defective.” Manufacturing defects in rolling element bearings make up less than one percent of the millions of bearings in use today around the world and this small defect percentage is being reduced continually by improvements in manufacturing techniques and bearing materials. Only a small fraction of all the bearings in use fail because they have reached their material fatigue limit. Most bearings outlive the machinery or component in which they are installed.

Q| Does the maintenance group understand what constitutes bearing fatigue life limits?

LOGIC: rolling element bearing life expectancy is directly related to the number of revolutions performed by the bearing, the magnitude of the load and the lubrication and cleanliness of the lubricant; assuming correct initial bearing selection and proper installation. Fatigue is the result of shear stresses, referred to as elastic deformation, cyclically appearing immediately below the load-carrying surface, as the rollers or balls pass over the raceway.

After many revolutions, these stresses between the rolling element and raceway surfaces will cause subsurface cracks to appear that will gradually extend to the surface of the rolling element, raceway, or both. These cracks may cause surface fragments of bearing material to break away. This condition is referred to as flaking or spalling that continues until the bearing has reached its life limit as illustrated below.


Q| Can the failure investigator explain the cause of the bearing failure illustrated below?

LOGIC: the frosted or smeared appearance of this bearing race illustrates what happens when the oil viscosity is too low (thin), and metal-to-metal contact occurs. This type of premature failure often occurs during initial start-up of heavily loaded bearings. This damage occurred after only 15 seconds of operation.

Q| Can the failure investigator recognize and explain the cause of the bearing failure illustrated below?

LOGIC: this bearing has failed due to continual welding contact between asperities on the metal surfaces, eventually causing metal to be ‘pulled out’ as the surfaces adhered to each other during rotation. This condition may have been caused by oil of the wrong viscosity, excessive load, speed, temperature, incorrect internal clearances, trapped contaminants or a combination of these conditions.

Even an increase of as little as 4° or 5° in temperature may contribute to these failures, due to unacceptable thinning of the lubricant’s viscosity. When analyzing the root cause of a failure, all the possible contributing causes must be considered.

Q| Can the failure analyst recognize and explain the cause of the two bearing failures illustrated below?

LOGIC: the rusting and white colouration on the outer race of the first bearing show a combination of several possible conditions; including small vibrations causing oscillation of the outer race, reddish discolouration of moisture in the bearing caused by poor sealing, poor fits between the outer raceway and housing, lack of lubrication or improper installation. The second bearing shows serious dark corrosion on the inner raceway equidistant between the rolling elements that occurred while the bearing was stationary.

Q| Can the failure analyst recognize and describe the bearing failure illustrated below?

LOGIC: over lubrication is frequently the cause of grease lubricated bearing failure causing higher than normal bearing operating temperatures. Excessive grease quantities cause internal friction within the lubricant, which in turn promotes excessive temperatures causing oxidation and premature lubricant and bearing failure.

Excessive quantities of grease cause a churning action within the rotating components and the result will always be an increase in temperature. Oil of too high viscosity or grease with a too high consistency will also increase operating temperatures. Care must be taken when investigating high temperatures, that the troubleshooter must consider not only the possibility of excessive lubricant, but that the correct lubricant for the application is in use.

Q| Can the failure analyst explain the cause of the bearing failure illustrated below?

LOGIC: bearings are not safe from potential electrostatic discharge or stray currents generated by electromagnetic forces. In these bearing applications, it is recommended that the bearing be grounded using grounding brushes.

For users of fan and electric motor belts and conveyors, the industry standards that define minimum conductivity are RMA IP-3-3, ISO 1813, and ISO 9563. In addition, drive belt manufacturers recommend the use of static conductive belts of six megohms or less. This bearing’s inner ring shows clear evidence of corrugated surface damage caused by electric pitting.

The challenge for troubleshooters is to learn to recognize the difference between the tiny percent of bearings that display material fatigue spalling that confirms their end of life and most bearings that display premature failures described above, because in many instances they look like the untrained eye.

It should come as no surprise to experienced equipment troubleshooters that assuming proper design, application, and lubrication, rolling element bearings will fail sooner or later due to their natural material fatigue life limit, but all bearings will fail prematurely from abuse or neglect.

L. (Tex) Leugner, author of Practical Handbook of Machinery Lubrication, is a 15-year veteran of the Royal Canadian Electrical Mechanical Engineers, where he served as a technical specialist. He was the founder and operations manager of Maintenance Technology International Inc. for 30 years. Tex holds an STLE lubricant specialist certification and is a millwright and heavy-duty mechanic. He can be reached at texleug@shaw.ca.

MROMAGAZINE

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Why Pump Shafts Often Break at the Keyway Area

By NTS Pump shaft failure can lead to significant downtime and repair costs in industrial plants. One of the most common locations for pump shaft failure is at the keyway area. In this article, we will explore the reasons why pump shafts often break at the keyway and what can be done to prevent such failures. The keyway is a high-stress point (weakest point)  on the shaft, where a key is inserted to transmit torque between the shaft and the pump impeller or coupling. During operation, the keyway experiences cyclic loading that creates a bending moment in the shaft, which is concentrated in the keyway area. Over time, this cyclic loading can cause fatigue failure in the shaft material, leading to a fracture at the keyway. In addition to cyclic loading, other factors can contribute to shaft failure at the keyway. Improper keyway design or installation can lead to stress concentrations or inadequate clearance between the key and keyway . Misalignment or overloading can also cause ex...

Grounding brush discharge monitoring

In recognition of the possibility of static charge build up in condensing steam turbines, API 612 (2005) specifies that grounding brushes be installed. The electrical flow to ground through these brushes  be monitored and useful information can be extracted. This article carries excerpts from the paper, “Babbitted bearing health assessment” by John K Whalen of John Crane, Thomas D Hess of Chestnut Run, Jim Allen of Nova Chemicals and Jack Craighton of Schneider Electric. Grounding brushes take current from the rotor to ground so that a charge does not build up on the rotor to the point where it discharges to ground though the best path possible – which is usually the closest point between the rotor and stator which is usually (hopefully) the point of minimum film thickness in a bearing. Typically this point of minimum film thickness is found in the active thrust bearing (as will be shown later). Shaft grounding brushes serve two purposes. The brushes are able to transmit modest amo...

Failures in babbit bearings

  There are literally dozens of ways bearings can fail. Some of the more common include: • Babbitt fatigue • Babbitt wiping due to rotor to stator contact • Babbitt flow due to high operating temperatures • Foreign particle damage • Varnish build-up • Electrostatic discharge damage (frosting) • Electromagnetic discharge damage (Spark tracks) • Oil “burn” or additive plating due to high temperatures • Loss of bond between babbitt and base metal • Chemical attack • Pivot wear in tilting pad bearings • Unloaded pad flutter • Cavitation damage This is taken from a paper, Babbitted bearing health assessment" by John Whalen of John Crane, Thomas Hess of Rotating Machinery Group, Jim Allen of Nova Chemicals Corporation and Jack Craighton of Schneider Electric. Babbitt fatigue Babbitt fatigue is caused by dynamic loads on the babbitt surface. Typically in bearings of this type, the dynamic loads are caused by vibration and result in peak film pressure fluct...

Failure investigation, remedies, and mitigation of a centrifugal pump.

  BY LUIS INFANTE & RODOLFO ALVARADO. A high energy pump at a water injection station in El Furrial, Venezuela exhibited extremely high vibration levels prior to an overhaul. It then suffered a catastrophic failure during startup following overhaul. The hydrodynamic bundle, rotor, and drive end (DE) bearing suffered damage.   High energy pump for boiler feed water. Courtesy of Flowserve. This centrifugal pump is a 3,000 HP, double-case volute, boiler feed water pump type. It has nine stages, outputs 750 gpm of water with suction pressure 1800 psi and discharge pressure 5250 psi. Rated speed was increased from 6000 to 6600 RPM to enhance the hydraulic performance. However, the pump’s actual discharge pressure was about 4,500 psi, well below the target value of 5,000 psi. The coupling was reportedly poorly fitted. The increased RPM created rotordynamic concerns of getting closer to a critical speed, thus the operator wanted to know about the synchronous regime. The...

John Crane's Type 28 Dry Gas Seals: How Does It Work?

How Does It Work? Highest Pressure Non-Contacting, Dry-Running Gas Seal Type 28 compressor dry-running gas seals have been the industry standard since the early 1980s for gas-handling turbomachinery. Supported by John Crane's patented design features, these seals are non-contacting in operation. During dynamic operation, the mating ring/seat and primary ring/face maintain a sealing gap of approximately 0.0002 in./5 microns, thereby eliminating wear. These seals eliminate seal oil contamination and reduce maintenance costs and downtime. John Crane's highly engineered Type 28 series gas seals incorporate patented spiral-groove technology, which provides the most efficient method for lifting and maintaining separation of seal faces during dynamic operation. Grooves on one side of the seal face direct gas inward toward a non-grooved portion of the face. The gas flowing across the face generates a pressure that maintains a minute gap between the faces, optimizing flui...